US government lawyers have invoked Iraq’s right to self-defence and the weakness of the Assad regime as twin justifications for US bombing in Syria, in a feat of legal acrobatics that may reopen questions over its right to intervene in the bitter civil war.
In a letter to the United Nations secretary general, Ban Ki-moon, released near 24 hours after attacks began, US ambassador Samantha Power argued that the threat to Iraq from Islamic State, known as Isis or Isil, gave the US and its allies in the region an automatic right to attack on its behalf.
“Iraq has made clear that it is facing a serious threat of continuing attacks from Isil coming out of safe havens in Syria,” Power wrote.
“The government of Iraq has asked that the United States lead international efforts to strike Isil sites and military strongholds in Syria in order to end the continuing attacks on Iraq, to protect Iraqi citizens and ultimately to enable and arm Iraqi forces to perform their task of regaining control of the Iraqi borders.”
The brief letter did not mention the US invasion of Iraq in 2003, which rested on erroneous claims of weapons of mass destruction and arguably contributed to its current instability, but stresses instead the country’s right to self-defence in the face of this new threat.
“The United States has initiated necessary and proportionate military actions in Syria in order to eliminate the ongoing Isil threat to Iraq, including by protecting Iraqi citizens from further attacks and by enabling Iraqi forces to regain control of Iraq’s borders,” it said.
The US also argued that there was legal right to pursue Isis inside Syria due to the weakness of that country’s government – a regime the US has been actively urging be undermined by rebel groups for much of the past two years.
“States must be able to defend themselves, in accordance with the inherent right on individual and collective self-defence, as reflected in article 51 of the UN Charter, when, as is the case here, the government of the state where the threat is located is unwilling or unable to prevent the use of its territory for such attacks,” Power wrote.
The legal circumlocutions to avoid requesting a UN security council resolution match similar efforts to avoid requesting specific legal authority from Congress.
Fearing that US politicians up for re-election in November may balk at voting for a third military attack on Iraq and being sucked into a Syrian quagmire, the White House has avoided seeking a fresh authorisation of the use of military force, preferring to rely on early authorisations against al-Qaida granted after the 11 September 2001 attacks.
read more >>
Wednesday, September 24, 2014
US ties itself in legal knots to cover shifting rationale for Syria strikes
Wednesday, September 24, 2014
No comments
Iraq,
ISIL,
Military Affairs,
Syria,
UN
About Islamic Societies Review
Islamic Societies Review Editors
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Most popular articles
-
War on Yemen Contrary to claims by Saudi Arabia that Iran is arming the Houthis, US State Department confirmed that this was not the ca...
-
By Andy Worthington As the prison-wide hunger strike in Guantánamo continues (sign the petition calling for its closure here!), nearly th...
-
Saudi attacks destroyed Yemen civilian planes Yemen's rebels fired rockets and mortars into Saudi Arabia on Tuesday, killing at le...
-
Chinese President Xi Jinping met his Tajik counterpart Emomali Rakhmon here on Monday, and the two leaders vowed to push ahead with bila...
-
by Nagham Assaad Morocco was not immune to the popular movement witnessed in the Arab region following the outbreak of the Tunisian ...
-
Thousands of people have rallied across Sweden expressing solidarity and support for Muslims after three attacks on mosques in just one wee...
-
The revelation is shocking, even for the CIA given the recent history of their modus operandi and even after we take into consideratio...
-
Syrian rebels attacked army positions in the northern province of Aleppo on Saturday while Islamist fighters clashed with Kurdish militi...
-
by Chris Stepheni The president of Libya's parliament, Mohamed al-Magariaf, has said military action is being considered against...

Frequently Used Labels and Topics
Academic Integrity
Adana Agreement
Africa
All
Arab Spring
Arts and Entertainment
Asia
BRICS
China
Civil society
Conflict
Constitutionalism
Crimes against humanity
Democracy
Dissent
Economics and Finance
Education and Communication
Egypt
Europe
Events
Genocide
Health
History and Civilizations
Human Rights
Ideas
Immigration
Inter
International Affairs
Iran
Iraq
ISIL
Islam in America
Islam Today
Journalism
Kurdistan
Law and Society
Majoritarianism
Media
Middle East
Military Affairs
Muslim Ban
Muslims
North Korea
Pakistan
Politics and Government
Populism
Poverty
Qatar
Racism
Religion and Culture
Religion and Politics
religion and society
Rohingya Genocide
Russia
Saudi Arabia
Science and Technology
Sectarianism
Sports
Syria
terrorism
Tunisia
Turkey
U.S. Foreign Policy
UN
United States
USA
wahhabism
War and Peace
War Crimes
World and Communities
Yemen

_______________________________________________
Copyright © Islamic Societies Review. All rights reserved.
Copyright © Islamic Societies Review. All rights reserved.

Blockchain Exchange
Recently reviewed
-
Saudi attacks destroyed Yemen civilian planes Yemen's rebels fired rockets and mortars into Saudi Arabia on Tuesday, killing at le...
-
By Andy Worthington As the prison-wide hunger strike in Guantánamo continues (sign the petition calling for its closure here!), nearly th...
-
War on Yemen Contrary to claims by Saudi Arabia that Iran is arming the Houthis, US State Department confirmed that this was not the ca...
-
Chinese President Xi Jinping met his Tajik counterpart Emomali Rakhmon here on Monday, and the two leaders vowed to push ahead with bila...
-
The notoriously secretive jihadi, who has never before been seen in public, chose the first Friday prayer service of Ramadan to make an au...
-
The Taliban has issued a statement directed at fighters in Iraq and Syria warning them against extremism in a clear rebuke to the Islamic...
-
The armed group calling itself "the islamic state" [IS] released another video depicting its cruel and unusual acts. The video d...
-
Interview Conducted By Bernhard Zand In an interview, Iraqi Foreign Minister Hoshyar Zebari, a Kurd, warns that his country is threat...
-
Like everywhere else in Syria, the rebel groups fighting in the Damascus region are badly divided on the ground. A year ago, one could i...
-
Seymour M. Hersh Barack Obama did not tell the whole story this autumn when he tried to make the case that Bashar al-Assad was respo...

Most read this month...
-
Saudi attacks destroyed Yemen civilian planes Yemen's rebels fired rockets and mortars into Saudi Arabia on Tuesday, killing at le...
-
By Andy Worthington As the prison-wide hunger strike in Guantánamo continues (sign the petition calling for its closure here!), nearly th...
-
War on Yemen Contrary to claims by Saudi Arabia that Iran is arming the Houthis, US State Department confirmed that this was not the ca...
-
Chinese President Xi Jinping met his Tajik counterpart Emomali Rakhmon here on Monday, and the two leaders vowed to push ahead with bila...
-
The armed group calling itself "the islamic state" [IS] released another video depicting its cruel and unusual acts. The video d...
-
Syrian rebels shelled Aleppo on Friday, killing three people, state television reported, a day after insurgents finished withdrawing from...
-
Summary CRISTINA FERNÁNDEZ, President of Argentina, said most of the problems facing the world today resulted from a lack of democratic ...
-
DONETSK, Ukraine — High-calibre weapons fire echoed sporadically Tuesday through the eastern city of Donetsk and the mayor urged resident...
-
ISR comment: For four years, some government officials from Syria , Iran , and Iraq have accused members of the U.S.-led anti-ISIL coalit...
-
The US is investigating a video which appears to show members of one of the Syrian rebel groups it has funded beheading a child. U.S. said ...

Most read last year
-
War on Yemen Contrary to claims by Saudi Arabia that Iran is arming the Houthis, US State Department confirmed that this was not the ca...
-
Saudi attacks destroyed Yemen civilian planes Yemen's rebels fired rockets and mortars into Saudi Arabia on Tuesday, killing at le...
-
By Andy Worthington As the prison-wide hunger strike in Guantánamo continues (sign the petition calling for its closure here!), nearly th...
-
Chinese President Xi Jinping met his Tajik counterpart Emomali Rakhmon here on Monday, and the two leaders vowed to push ahead with bila...
-
Summary CRISTINA FERNÁNDEZ, President of Argentina, said most of the problems facing the world today resulted from a lack of democratic ...
-
The armed group calling itself "the islamic state" [IS] released another video depicting its cruel and unusual acts. The video d...
-
Syrian rebels shelled Aleppo on Friday, killing three people, state television reported, a day after insurgents finished withdrawing from...
-
DONETSK, Ukraine — High-calibre weapons fire echoed sporadically Tuesday through the eastern city of Donetsk and the mayor urged resident...
-
The US is investigating a video which appears to show members of one of the Syrian rebel groups it has funded beheading a child. U.S. said ...
-
By Eric Bennett Did the CIA fund creative writing in America? The idea seems like the invention of a creative writer. Yet once upon a ti...

No comments:
Write comments